Monday, February 08, 2016

Just say no to equity market drugs

Given the choice between scratching out a quick post or listening to Coldplay caterwauling at halftime of the Super Bowl, Macro Man didn't really face much of a choice at all.  There is plenty of interest to discuss in financial markets, certainly more than the the ouevre of the Super Bowl halftime act can muster.

Let's start with China, where the PBOC announced over the weekend that FX reserves had fallen another $99 billion in January.   This not-insubstantial sum was met with a quelle horreur! reaction from the mainstream press, though in fact it was substantially less than that implied by the intervention estimates that have been bandied about around the street.   Not that they are mutually exclusive; there is a chance that the PBOC conducted some intervention via the forward market, which would make sense given the blowout in domestic rates last month.   Lending RMB onshore for, say, 3 months in addition to injecting liquidity might explain how quickly the rates market returned to relative normalcy after the blowout.  Perhaps we'll know in a few months.

In any event, the chart below offers a simple schematic of China's FX flows, decomposed into bank FX purchases (PBOC plus private sector), FX deposits, FDI, trade, and portfolio flows.   You can clearly see the blowout in the latter over the past year, though it is instructive to observe how it is largely offsetting prior capital inflows (which is not what one would expect from a country running a large C/A surplus.)  As noted earlier, to some degree the drawdown in FX reserves simpy represents a healthy reallocation of China's NIIP from the public to the private sectors.   In any event, nothing's gonna happen this week thanks to the lunar New Year celebrations.


Switching gears to the US, Friday's post-payroll price action was telling, insofar as it was all about the equity pain trade.  This is certainly one of those environments where what's going on under the hood is more interesting than top-level beta analysis.  Macro Man highlighted the new "equity market crack" trade of long NDX/short XLE last month; while that wasn't quite the ding-dong high it was close enough, as the spread has rolled over nicely.   An orthodox 38.2% retracement would suggest another 10-12% downside from here.

If the spread above is equity crack, then the real junkies probably go for the really hard stuff: equity market smack.  Long FANG and short GDX was a prodigious trade over the past several years, with that spread rising  more than 10-fold from Facebook's IPO in May 2012 to Thanksgiving of last year.   The high was great while it lasted, but coming down has proven to be unpleasant to say the least.  If you wanted one chart to illustrate the pain in equity space, this would be the one.   As Macro Man noted last week, GDX looks like breaking out, potentially inflicting more pain.

 Remember kids:  just because your friends do it doesn't make it right.  Just say not to drugs!

66 comments:

  1. Central banks are buying stocks and the market isn't even open

    ReplyDelete
  2. your new blog maquette is much much nicer than Superbowl 50 half time stomach upset

    did you notice they didn't call it 'Superbowl L'

    ReplyDelete
  3. I guess the good news is that GDX I bought at $22 is looking somewhat less stupid than it did....

    ReplyDelete
  4. dude, I understand that Jack Lambert wasn't on the pitch but 11 sacks? DEs running the 40s in 4.7 just like a CB make that game still entertaining...

    Question of the day: will Mario line up a shotgun offense in March? he may be forced to play a Hail Mary pass... but I wonder who the receivers are going to be...

    ciao for now
    ff

    ReplyDelete
  5. Holiday week.Big dax level. Could get 6-800 point rally this week if holds up. Same as last Chinese week off and THanksgiving.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anon 8:25here - thankthe Lord for risk tight stops!

    ReplyDelete
  7. algomoron is a moronFebruary 8, 2016 at 12:07 PM

    Hey moron, how about you go long dax, blow your account and stop boring us? Run along now...

    ReplyDelete
  8. I thought the half time show was pretty good!

    MM & Co, what are your thoughts here on the 5yr? its been in a range of 1.2-1.8 since the fed telegraphing the end of QE in 2013....at the lower range now.. worth a punt with tight stops?

    Interest rates are non stop this whole year so far. Very strong intermediate trend. I think this is really spooking a lot of equity guys, that along with Yen threatening to break 116 and EZ equities collapsing (and oil and China ;-)

    I guess EZ equities arent delivering earnings? Just a cursory glance, Intesa Sanpaolo, now yielding 5-6%. I would think at some point pension funds might find that attractive vs the 0.26 on bunds

    But momentum is to the downside, so not for me just yet

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ugly morning ahead. Another rendition of the 1812 overture this week? Retest of the lows in crude, or new depths?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Indeed it looks ugly, with USDJPY on the cliff.
    Nevertheless, it is probably worth mentionning that the Eurostoxx50 is touching, as we speak, the 50% fibo of the whole move from the lows in 2009 to the highs in April 2015 @ 2'800.
    Abee, there are several names that are attractive at these valuations with, bear in mind, estimates already slashed substantially for 2016. Take Daimler, 7x ntm P/E, 5% DY and 30% of the market cap in cash .... nobody wants it. It's a buyer's strike and clearly expectations for a full blown recession in the coming quarters is getting baked into the market.

    ReplyDelete
  11. While I thought EZ earnings might be the culprit, since its less than half way through EZ season (which starts later) I doubt that is the real source. Seems more likely just the Financials sector (DB, CS, HSBC etc) dragging down the index. When banks outperform its been a pretty good risk on signal for EZ.

    http://imgur.com/GhdVX4K

    Eurostoxx in yellow vs Bank Index/Eurostoxx.

    HSBC below 2011 lows
    UBS 57% above 2011 lows
    BNP 60% above 2011 lows
    Barclays 32% above 2011 lows
    CS at 2011 lows
    Llyods 175% above 2011 lows
    Santander below 2011 lows
    DB below 2011 lows and near 2009 levels
    SocGen 100% above 2011 lows
    Intesa Sanpaolo - 160% above 2011 lows


    ReplyDelete
  12. Indeed, ugly as the day is long. Financial markets are basically saying that we're in recession in the Eurozone. Message couldn't be clearer. I don't buy it, and hence I have to assume you can buy this dip. But it does feel like a step into a dark void at the moment!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I can remember the old definition of expert in my business...In the old days, an expert was a bubba who gave a lecture more than 60 miles from home and had his own set of slides..

    ...I notice there are still lots of experts in the powerpoint generation running around...and CNBC does a nice job with graphs...


    ...How's their investing history in bear markets? A little tougher to ascertain...

    ReplyDelete
  14. Time to close long bund/ short BTPS for me. Lost my call spread on SX5e but HAPPY to be in cash. Really happy...

    ReplyDelete
  15. Probably but i've done 35 bps since beginning.. it has covered all my losses around and i'm sensing that we're ready for a bounce of risky assets... maybe...

    ReplyDelete
  16. So according to ZH, MM lives in infamy these days?

    ReplyDelete
  17. I thought we were feeling gravity after the bounce!

    ReplyDelete
  18. @MM... oopss...you we're right...wtf

    ok, IT'S A COLLAPSE AROUND

    ReplyDelete
  19. Chesapeak restructures, and MLP's are getting killed. Smells of bottom !!

    The market is really questioning MLP business model here. Suddenly we dont need piplines

    ReplyDelete
  20. I heard the CDS of DB is spiking, along with CHK collapsing, this looks like a perfect storm.

    I guess that I am dreaming that anons here are right about CBs buying....

    ReplyDelete
  21. Font euribors trading lower as SX7E makes new lows provides a faint whiff of sulphur with respect to systemic/contagion risks....

    ReplyDelete
  22. Yes, this is my last hedge... honestly not so sure that we'll be pleased by this trade working...

    CB talking heads now totally absent by any comment..really stupid, they've talked a lot wrongly in november and now stay silent.

    ReplyDelete
  23. But they spoke all last week and we still sold off. The gig is up on CB talk. They need strong action, if that works at all.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Fed- 4-hike dot plot
    ECB- "whatever it takes"
    BoE- "sharper relief"
    BOJ- negative rate shock

    Markets may be losing faith in central banks

    ReplyDelete
  25. Information density of Comments now very low.

    NB comment on the new layout not on posters... :)

    ReplyDelete
  26. Infact, no more NIRP please.... they're missing a huge hike in sistemic risks.. if they don't act in a wise way (revision of bail in, a G20 agreement on no more devaluation, etc), only a European TARP will stop this bloodbath.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This below is something in the right direction, but nothing related to today's action


    Bank of Canada Says Fiscal Policy Can Help Financial Stability
    By Theophilos Argitis
    (Bloomberg) -- Financial stability risks may be one more reason for the federal government to consider ramping up fiscal stimulus.
    In a speech today in Montreal, Bank of Canada Deputy Governor Tim Lane laid out the challenges of central banks grappling with the impact of historically low borrowing costs on financial stability, including record household indebtedness.
    The Bank of Canada’s ability to control financial stability risks are limited given its inflation-fighting mandate, and “macroprudential” policies such as housing regulation and even fiscal policy have scope to tackle the problem, Lane said.
    Lane said recent Bank of Canada research suggests that using monetary policy to reduce vulnerabilities in the financial system are costly and better handled by regulations to rein in housing debt.
    “One thing is clear,” Bank of Canada Deputy Governor Tim Lane said. “Monetary policy cannot take primary responsibility for maintaining financial stability.”
    “Other, prudential, tools are required to build a resilient financial system and, where needed, to address increasing vulnerabilities,” Lane said.
    There may also be cases where policy makers should refrain from using macroprudential regulations, said Lane.
    “Thus, it is possible that, in a situation of sustained weak aggregate demand, relying primarily on monetary policy to provide stimulus may lead to financial vulnerabilities that macroprudential policy cannot, or should not, offset,” Lane said.
    “In such circumstances, fiscal policy may be called upon to provide stimulus, particularly since it is likely to be more effective at low interest rates.

    ReplyDelete
  28. wow EZ equities smoked for a week bonds explode and my calls have halved...hmph..
    now that every equity punter i know is showing me DB cds and has become an expert in COCOs me thinks turn is near , along with barrons $20 oil call
    guess time will tell but have "averaged" into some sx5e calls( i know , don't add to losers an all that)

    ReplyDelete
  29. ". . . only a European TARP will stop this bloodbath."

    Perhaps. But a bloodbath, unmitigated by CBs, is desperately needed to fix the system.

    ReplyDelete
  30. http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-02-08/europe-closes-lows-deutsche-bank-plunges-11-7-year-lows

    ReplyDelete
  31. Folks, we have to bear in mind that Central Banks NIRP has CAUSED this collapse in banks, and the associated knock-on effect in financial markets. This message needs to be made very clear. Central Banks are the CAUSE of the problem, not the solution. It's time they were held to account and faced punishment.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Maybe I'm biased toward a sector too narrow but generally gonna agree with this article:

    http://acrossthecurve.com/?p=24667

    Even though CL1/SPX correlation may have lost some grip recently still think generally going to the same direction. When oil bottoms due to supply problems, equities will bottom as well, so that's the thing to watch for me. I think close to $20, it'll still take a little bit time to get there, meanwhile finances across the sector continue to deteriorate faster from lower revenues. What does that equate in SPX though, not sure. The final stage should need to involve a much bigger puke in majors who keep the gravity defying divvies, especially EU companies. Even CVX/XOM aren't as safe as you think, from their own relative point of view they experience balance sheet deterioration too and the question is how far management will let it. This is an essential purge of CB policy excesses that needs to happen at some poine (why not now), but the unfortunate thing is that the sector apparently accounted so much of US growth that it turned into a bigger drag than most participants currently think.

    Meanwhile GDX and TLT continue having field days and all mREITs do ok relative to the rest of the market.

    ReplyDelete
  33. @anon 5:11

    we agree, my hope (really feeble...) is that they will realize that... or at least that they will push hardly on fiscal side..

    ReplyDelete
  34. We're gonna have a perfect storm. An EU banking crisis is re-surfacing, we're gonna have sovereign defaults in Europe... the ECB will panic and go NIRP and moar QE. This will further pressure the USD, hurting China and the US who will respond forcibly. The inept BOJ will further aggravate the situation for everyone.

    The central bank end-game is approaching. Let's face it, all CB monetary policy was just a ponzi. You can't solve a debt crisis with more debt. We will learn this lesson in the next 2-3 months.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Easy - have the CBs cancel as much of the Government debt stock as is needed to support expansionary fiscal policy. Cancel the whole lot of it (and more) until morale improves.

    [should it ever be needed - which I sorely doubt - but to emphasise the extent to which policy could be extended *if* required]

    ReplyDelete
  36. @anon 6:09

    Spot on. Central Banks and governments, when viewed as a single entity, have done nothing but print money and promise (cross their hearts!) to collect it in taxes someday.

    Gee I wonder how this movie ends

    ReplyDelete
  37. Let's see whether 1800 holds over the next few days. If it is taken out I smell a bit of fresh ait between here and 1600.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Yellon is going to testify on Wed, it would be interesting to see if she treated last week's NFP wage data as a signal of higher inflation or a lagging indicator of the economy. So there maight be some mini-rebound later this week.

    On another note, http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2016/02/05/almost-every-top-official-in-texas-city-arrested-in-federal-corruption-case/

    "Almost every top official in a remote South Texas city was arrested Thursday under a detailed federal indictment that accuses them of taking bribes from contractors and sending city workers to help an illegal gambling operator nicknamed "Mr. T.""

    I wonder why I have not seen Mr. T's comment on the market for a while on this blog and now there may be a clue.

    ReplyDelete
  39. LB is in a remote South Texas city this week but hasn't seen Mr T.

    We are loving us some Hammock Time this week and happy to hold a large amount of the asset du jour. Cash. The Kevlar gloves remained in the drawer Friday and they are still there. No need to lose an important appendage, eh CV?

    Brutal YTD for leveraged longs, small cap long-only and general FANG funds. Just brutal. One's main worry now is what starts to happen when those investors liquidate, request redemptions and generally shit their pants in every conceivable way. Dame Janet will be aware that somewhere below SPX 1800 lurks a void, and within that void be Despair.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Usdjpy should find support somewhere between here and 114, which would likely herald SPX 1800-1812. Until that happens, and in view of the Slough of Despond lies beyond those levels (Usdjpy 110 and SPX ????), we are proceeding with extreme caution for the time being. The action in US10y is amazing, that was really all unleashed by the BoJ NIRP announcement, which we hadn't anticipated. We had a very small rates trade that has now gone to the home for very small rates trades in the sky...

    Crude oil can easily take another two days of beatings, so can Usdjpy and EU financials. No need to be a hero....

    ReplyDelete
  41. @anon 7:03, that made me chuckle. I've been quiet, don't have much to say. I've got some basket plays going but in general have put this market into the "too hard" category for now. Flat is the new killing it and all..

    ReplyDelete
  42. NYFedResearch cues up 10 blog posts on fixed income liquidity (including 3rd Ave collapse in Dec)

    http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2016/02/continuing-the-conversation-on-liquidity.html#.Vrj4FrkrJGG

    ReplyDelete
  43. Equities rallying sharply towards the US close. Central Banks on the bid.

    ReplyDelete
  44. ". . . only a European TARP will stop this bloodbath."

    it is so annoying to have to read this some of you you guys need to step up the level (of thinking) and stop acting like children

    1) you do not seem to know Europe
    2) you do not seem to know how to deal with bear markets
    3) you have no idea, or forgot how much pain they inflict before (or in order to) turn around

    those last years i said many times that the morons (FM and his anonymous clique) who started trading from 2009 onwards or worse, the older traders who CHANGED their way of thinking because of 6 years of continuous QE/CBs spa treatment will lose all their money when the bear hits.

    Your brain has been totally taken over by POMO. If you are still long this market because you did not actively trail your profits from the 6 year ramp up you can only blame yourself when the market swallows it all back, you may even lose more if you do not plan your exit and freeze.

    Just use a multi year chart - you can trade 1700 on spoos, or 1600 (my favorite) or even 1400 and still keep a bullish multi year picture.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Reuters:
    More than 40 percent of the 7 trillion euro-denominated government bond market in Europe has yields below zero

    2.9 trillion euros ($3.2 trillion) worth of sovereign bonds have a negative yield

    48 billion euros worth of investment grade corporate bonds in Europe carry negative yields

    And the credit cycle is rolling over ( at least according to Gundlach )

    Can someone explain why the Central Banks have decided to throw their domestic banks under the bus. Is the end game to nationalize?

    ReplyDelete
  46. MM, how come some names of posters are in white and some dark? Is there a code or is there a test we must pass :)

    ReplyDelete
  47. LOL @ nico. I bet FM made more money in 3 mths than nico made in his life.

    ReplyDelete
  48. "Equities rallying sharply towards the US close. Central Banks on the bid."

    shut up it has nothing to do with central banks. Some traders are just TRADING and making money while you are watching.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Gee. JP Morgan just gave Geithner a Credit Line to Invest With Warburg Pincus...

    ReplyDelete
  50. US indexes reversing their -2% losses in 30 mins. Thank you "Ramp Capital LLC".

    ReplyDelete
  51. anon845

    not wishing to debate penis size here, you do need to know i am trading clips of 50 lots on estoxx, or 20 eminis, for the last 20 years. My biggest size was 500 stoxx in 2008. Those are almost investment banking punts. Try to understand what it means for a lifestyle. I am really tempted to forget this blog because of trolls like you. You really bring nothing to the community

    ReplyDelete
  52. Children, come on, play nicely. I guess I am going to have to start doing something about he random 'CB buying equities' posts because they are clearly trolling. I'd really appreciate it if the comments didn't devolve into a " A makes more than B" schoolyard argument.

    As for the comments, if you are registered with Blogger you get your name in white. Otherwise it's dark. On ethe front page if you click on the "53 comments" link it takes you to the old-style comments page.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Nico, ignore the clowns mate, anyone who has been in the market long enough values your input.
    MM I seldom contribute, but please do something about this flood of trolls...makes even lurking unpleasant...tia

    ReplyDelete
  54. MM time to axe the anons. There is enough class registered by name not to need them. If people want to play then they can at least make that small commitment to play under a name. If they aren't willing to do that then do you need them?

    Pol.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Nico G-

    Been reading some of your comments as a long time reader of this great blog and thank you for them. I may or may not agree but they add a v good perspective from a different point of looking at the market. Very healthy to read them IMO to me at least. Cheers from a Frenchy punter in London

    ReplyDelete
  56. Say what you like about Aghi, Trichet would have hiked twice by now.

    ReplyDelete
  57. And there we go. First troll deleted.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Kindly piss off back to whatever dunghill, intellectual or physical, from whence you emerged.

    ReplyDelete
  59. You didn't find either of my posts funny? Why this hostile tone?

    ReplyDelete
  60. Because I am tired of trolling comments and people ignoring requests to be civil and not act like idiots.

    ReplyDelete
  61. @nico:
    You were talking about a bullish bet on sx5e some days ago, changed your mind?
    However according to you markets need to be fixed by themselves... You defined a level random at 1400.. Why not 748 or 1047?
    I'm 95 %cash but this doesnt solve any problem. If according to you everything is shit,ok you're a permabear. But please give us some scenario where risky assets stop to fall or is it impossibile? What could changed this state of the world?

    ReplyDelete
  62. Abee: I think CHK is just the beginning. I don't think it's their pipeline biz that is the problem, but their gas plays.
    I think these charts are the most import tools to determine the fate of tight oil and gas companies.
    Decline rate
    Rig count
    So tight wells run down about 80% in 60mnth or so and drilling started declining Q1 15.
    So based on that. The way I see it is, these companys have a ton of debt and are going to pump to beat the band to service that debt. Their going to pump till the wells go dry. That should be happening this year or early next (I'm sure a sharp penciled analyst could peg each co to the month)
    The other kicker is economically recoverable reserves, I believe they are based on year end price or a moving average. Either way reserves should also be tanking soon with balance sheet pain to follow.
    So I expect more is to come.
    As an aside. I've been struggling with the notion of SPX/INDU or what ever, correlation with $WTIC. Oil fell out of bed the middle of 2014. SPX figured this out when January? Seems like the popular meme for now so I'll go with it till other wise.
    Anyway if anyone has any colour or corrections to the above I'd be happy to hear. I'm just a macro tourist here!

    ReplyDelete
  63. There is something else one might consider and that is a bear market in a ZIRP world. How might the Bear go forward if zero rates change things....? As I doodle through it, it seems to me it might have less of a dampening effect, that is, bonds and cd's one might think go toward softening the effects of the equities bear market as they are a place to hide when the investor is losing money and leaving stocks. But the polices of the Fed have taken that foundation away, and when John Q Investor seems his net worth go down month by month, it would seem to me he will MORE speedily withdraw money since there is not an alternate investment that might temper the bruising he's getting.

    2 cnets...

    ReplyDelete
  64. Bear market in a ZIRP world? Sure, Japan had years of that. I have no problem whatsoever imagining such a thing.

    This is a situation where you have to think globally. There may be years when you can't make any money in your own country between ZIRP, low rates and falling equities. So you search the world for yield and punting opportunities to make a living. Yes?

    ReplyDelete